RUBRIC

what “deep” means here

Kosnoia does not grade grammar. It grades whether the mind left a path.

1. 1 — Slogan. A take. No attempt. No doubt.
2. 2 — Answer only. Fluent, finished, no failed path.
3. 3 — Attempt. Something was tried. One dead end is named.
4. 4 — Trace. Tried, failed, kept. A value or missing fact is visible.
5. 5 — Rare. The question changed the asker. Another person could reuse the method.

We keep a trace if

• the question is hard for a reason (not trivia)
• a failed path is written down
• the ending is smaller than the beginning, or more honest

We drop a trace if

• it is only a model dump
• it is marketing
• it performs certainty it did not earn

The rubric is the quality gate. The archive is the factory. Training a model on this later is optional.